> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.jaffnamonitor.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# A Jar of Mud and the Politics of Empty Gestures
- URL: https://www.jaffnamonitor.com/a-jar-of-mud-and-the-politics-of-empty-gestures/
- Published: 2026-11-22T07:17:56.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T07:17:56.000Z
- Author: M.R. Narayan Swamy
- Tags: November 2026

**By M.R. Narayan Swamy**

Tamil Nadu political leader Thol. Thirumavalavan’s scooping of mud from Velupillai Prabhakaran’s now-demolished house in Sri Lanka reminds me of an earlier era when another politician in the Indian state vowed to grow his beard until an independent Tamil Eelam came into being.

Since the promised Tamil Eelam never emerged, R. Janarthanam never shaved his beard after making his headline-grabbing announcement in the presence of the veteran MGR in the 1980s.

Thirumavalavan’s action during his November 2026 visit to Velvettiturai or VVT in Jaffna did not create a similar stir since the movement to carve out Tamil Eelam lies in ruins – much like Prabhakaran’s childhood home razed by the Sri Lankan military.

What Thirumavalavan will do with the mud he took home in a glass jar is not known. One thing is certain. He won’t flaunt it before Congress star Rahul Gandhi, a political ally in Tamil Nadu whose father was assassinated by the Tamil Tigers on Prabhakaran’s fiat.

More importantly, nothing the Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK) leader does with the earth from VVT will in any way contribute to the betterment of the Tamil-speaking people in Sri Lanka’s north and east.

Indeed, this has been so since politicians in Tamil Nadu, split from Sri Lanka by a strip of sea, began taking an active interest in the escalating armed struggle in Sri Lanka for a Tamil homeland.

The anti-Tamil pogrom in Colombo in 1983 birthed predictable anger in Tamil Nadu. The fury was genuine on Tamil Nadu’s streets. This provoked an intense political drama as MGR/AIADMK and Karunanidhi/DMK tried to portray themselves as more sincere towards the Tamils in the island nation.

MGR gave the militants sanctuary, and he had a soft corner for Prabhakaran and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). All militant groups set up training camps in the state, with the blessings of both the central and state governments.

MGR felt no wrong in fostering a culture of brutal violence and militancy-laced thuggery in Sri Lanka; although he dealt with Naxalites in his own state with an iron hand, his administration killing suspected Maoists without mercy.

When MGR died and Karunanidhi took power, he allowed the LTTE, by then the sole masters of Sri Lanka’s north and east, a free run of Tamil Nadu, leading to the massacre of the EPRLF leadership in Chennai in 1990 and of former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi near Chennai in 1991.

In the long years they were mass leaders in Tamil Nadu, neither MGR nor Karunanidhi felt like counselling Prabhakaran that he was headed on an unending confrontationist path that would only result in misery to the Tamils he claimed to represent.

It is another matter that Prabhakaran may or may not have listened to them. But the fact is that these two charismatic figures never did anything positive for the Tamils in Sri Lanka except providing money and overt support to the militants.

Looking back, Tamil Nadu’s tallest leaders could have tried to mediate in the Sri Lankan conflict, offering to act as a bridge between Colombo and the militants. It was not to be.

A time came when people at large in Tamil Nadu, due to a variety of factors, began losing sympathy for the LTTE & Co. But it became a fashion in Tamil Nadu’s politics to flaunt one’s loyalty to the Tigers, although it failed to yield political dividend.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f0/aa/f0aaf7b7-6b61-437a-846a-1a80de683912/content/images/2026/11/a-jar-of-mud-and-the-folly-of-31b8d8-1.png)

Thol. Thirumavalavan collecting soil from the site of Velupillai Prabhakaran’s demolished ancestral home in Valvettithurai, Jaffna.

DMK veteran-turned-rebel Vaiko did not feel he was doing any wrong when he made a clandestine boat trip to Sri Lanka in the 1980s – without telling his own party leader. Ditto for P. Nedumaran, who was among the few politicians in Tamil Nadu whose closeness to Prabhakaran was considered genuine. But even he blundered when he claimed that the LTTE chief was alive and would make a grand appearance – years after he was killed!

It was in 1989 that Tamil journalist D. Sivaram (Taraki) predicted that PMK leader S.R. Ramadoss had a great future in Tamil Nadu. Although I knew Taraki and generally respected his analysis, I was amused by his PMK reading, which went wrong because it was written from a narrow Sri Lankan prism.

In August 2009, two months after the LTTE was routed, noted Indian agricultural scientist M.S. Swaminathan hurriedly cancelled a visit to Sri Lanka to help farmers revive agriculture in the Tamil-majority north due to loud criticism from Tamil Nadu politicians. The trip could have helped Tamil farmers seeking to recover from years of war but became a victim of Tamil Nadu’s fratricidal politics.

Once the LTTE cracked down on other Tamil groups, scores of former militants struggled to live in Tamil Nadu. They were as Tamil as the Tigers. Yet no known Tamil Nadu politician went to their rescue. Many eventually made it to the West with the help of friends and relatives. Some still slog in Tamil Nadu.

If only Tamil Nadu leaders could draw a line between the larger Sri Lanka and the mass of Tamils there, they could have come up with plans to boost the battered economy in the north and east of the island nation. Remember, if the DMK had not given up its separatist agenda in 1962, it could not have contributed to making Tamil Nadu one of India’s most successful economies today. Yet, no such advise was ever shared with the militants and others in Sri Lanka.

Thirumalavan’s scooping of the earth from Prabhakaran’s family home, now overrun by wild vegetation, should be seen in this context. It is another act of dramatics. It will neither help the ordinary Tamils in Sri Lanka nor fetch votes in Tamil Nadu. As Seeman realised in Tamil Nadu, waving the LTTE flag at campaign rallies cannot guarantee popular support.

People want leaders who promise and deliver a better tomorrow – and not get bogged down by yesterday’s conflict and mayhem. Tamils in Sri Lanka too deserve better. Do also note that there is no sympathy in the larger international community for the now defunct LTTE and its leadership.

Yes, there are genuine issues concerning the community; those should not be confused with the imperative need to improve the economic lot of the people.

The other day, Sri Lankan President Anura Dissanayake told JVP members that “we must develop a new way of thinking, transform ourselves in new ways, and adopt a mindset and approach capable of overcoming the new challenges before us”. This came from a Marxist revolutionary who realises the need to reform. It may not be a bad idea for Tamil leaders to emulate him and graduate out of a world where the only words that seem to matter are Prabhakaran, Eelam and federalism.