> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.jaffnamonitor.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Chemmani: Why Are Tamil Lawyer-Politicians Reluctant to Date the Dead?
- URL: https://www.jaffnamonitor.com/featured/chemmani-why-are-tamil-lawyer-politicians-reluctant-to-date-the-dead/
- Published: 2026-11-20T14:14:23.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T14:14:23.000Z
- Author: Aruliniyan Mahalingam
- Tags: JM Exclusive, November 2026

**By Aruliniyan Mahalingam**

**JAFFNA, Sri Lanka:** A forensic technique used in criminal investigations around the world could show within months whether most of the people exhumed at Chemmani died during Sri Lanka’s civil war or long before it, and it needs only milligrams of bone or tooth. When the Jaffna Magistrate’s Court took up the question of testing the remains on Thursday, no one asked it to use that technique.

The families of the disappeared are represented by a team of about 20 lawyers. They include K.S. Ratnavel, a senior President’s Counsel who opened the families’ submissions, and M.A. Sumanthiran, a President’s Counsel and general secretary of the Ilankai Tamil Arasu Kachchi, who made the case for DNA testing. Nearly all of the families’ lawyers opposed a police request to carbon-date the remains, according to accounts of the proceedings. None proposed another way to establish when the dead were buried.

Speaking to reporters after the hearing, Mr. Sumanthiran said carbon dating could be carried out but could not be treated as conclusive. DNA, he said, was the only test that could give certainty on identification.

DNA can identify the dead, but it cannot tell when they died. Every other question at Chemmani depends on the answer to that one.

## **Why ordinary carbon dating falls short**

Living things take in carbon, including a trace of radioactive carbon-14\. After death, the intake stops, and the carbon-14 decays at a known rate, so the amount left in bone indicates how long ago the person lived.

For recent centuries the method is blunt. The curve used to convert laboratory results into calendar years is nearly flat between about 1650 and 1950, so a single result can fit several date ranges spread across 300 years.

In 2019, Beta Analytic, a laboratory in Florida, reported that six bone samples from the Mannar mass grave dated to between the late 15th and early 18th centuries, and the excavation was halted. At Matale, where 155 skeletons were found at a hospital site in 2012, results from the same laboratory were interpreted by Douglas Ubelaker of the Smithsonian Institution as showing burials before 1950\. A presidential commission found in 2015 that the remains had no link to the disappearances of 1989 and 1990\. Both results were disputed, and both have since been cited against Tamil claims about mass graves.

Mr. Sumanthiran cites those two cases as the basis for his reservations. Whatever one concludes about them, the limits of conventional dating for recent remains are real.

Jaffna adds a complication. People who eat a lot of fish absorb older carbon from the sea, which can make their bones appear older than they are, in some cases by centuries. Laboratories can estimate and correct for this by measuring stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes in the same sample, but only if the testing is designed that way from the start.

## **A clock set by nuclear tests**

A far more precise method exists for deaths in the modern era. It relies on a byproduct of the Cold War.

Atmospheric nuclear tests in the 1950s and early 1960s nearly doubled the amount of carbon-14 in the atmosphere by the mid-1960s. After the Partial Test Ban Treaty of 1963, the level began a long decline that continues today. Anyone whose bones or teeth formed after the mid-1950s carries that excess. Forensic scientists call it the bomb pulse and measure it by accelerator mass spectrometry, which counts carbon-14 atoms directly. It is the same radiocarbon measurement, read against a much sharper reference curve.

In a 2006 review, Mr. Ubelaker and Bruce Buchholz of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory wrote that the absence of bomb carbon generally indicates death before 1950\. The method dates when a tissue formed, not when a person died or was buried. Bone renews slowly, so its carbon reflects years or decades before death. A 2015 study by Mr. Ubelaker and colleagues found that the lag grows with age.

Teeth avoid most of that problem. Enamel forms in childhood and never renews. In 2005, researchers led by Kirsty Spalding and Jonas Frisén reported in Nature that bomb carbon in enamel could fix a person’s birth year to within about 1.6 years.

That makes the method particularly suited to Chemmani. By the archaeologists’ preliminary estimates, about 63 percent of the dead were children or infants. For a child who died young, the years the teeth formed are close to the year of death. Children born in the 1980s or 1990s will carry the bomb signal in their teeth, and children born in the 1920s will not.

The method can be designed to withstand the kind of challenge raised over Mannar and Matale. A credible program would test a planned selection of adults and children from each layer of the trench, including skeletons reported to show binding or injury and those found with modern objects. Samples would be split and sent blind to at least two accredited laboratories abroad, with correction for diet and with the families’ observers present when the samples are taken.

The ground supplies further evidence. Where newer graves cut through older ones, the sequence of burials can be read. Objects found with the dead set the earliest possible date of burial: a plastic button cannot be older than plastic. Luminescence dating of grave soil is possible, but its margins of error are too wide to separate one recent decade from another.

None of this has been put before the court.

## **Why it has not been proposed**

Several lawyers familiar with the case told Jaffna Monitor that the reason is political. They spoke on condition of anonymity because the case is before the court. They alleged that Tamil politicians acting as lawyers for the families oppose dating because they believe the remains may not be connected to the war, and that establishing their age could undermine the account those politicians have built around Chemmani as a wartime mass grave.

“It will of course reduce their political mileage,” one lawyer said.

The lawyers acknowledged that conventional carbon dating gives only an approximate time frame. They said more precise techniques are available, and that the failure to propose any of them reflects a fear of what a clear chronology would show. They said DNA identification on its own could never close the case. If one set of samples failed to match, the politicians could argue that the right families had not yet come forward and ask for another round, and then another.

They pointed to Mr. Sumanthiran’s remarks after the hearing. “While such testing may be carried out, it cannot be treated as conclusive evidence,” he said of carbon dating, according to a translation of his remarks in Tamil. “As far as identification is concerned, DNA testing is the only scientific test that can provide certainty.” In the lawyers’ reading, he was discounting in advance any date the court might obtain, while backing a method that cannot produce one.

Jaffna Monitor could not independently verify what the politicians privately believe.

## **What three DNA samples can do**

Mr. Sumanthiran filed affidavits on Thursday from relatives of three people documented as having disappeared, offering their DNA for comparison. The court ordered the affidavits kept in its safe after he said the relatives feared harassment by the security forces.

“The primary objective when skeletal remains are discovered is to establish whose remains they are,” he said. He said he had been pressing for DNA testing since August 2025.

A match would be decisive. It would name a victim, and the record of that person’s disappearance would date the death. With three families and at least 574 sets of remains, the odds of a match are low even if the site does hold victims of the war. Mr. Sumanthiran has told the court he expects more families to come forward.

DNA identification on a large scale takes years. In Bosnia, the International Commission on Missing Persons collected 87,931 blood samples from relatives of 28,964 missing people and had made about 13,000 identifications by 2010, using a dedicated laboratory network. Sri Lanka has no laboratory equipped to extract DNA from remains like those at Chemmani. Bone buried for decades in tropical heat often yields degraded DNA, and many parents of the young people who disappeared in Jaffna in 1996 have since died.

Forensic investigations of mass graves usually combine the two kinds of evidence, dating to establish when and DNA to establish who. Dating first would show which remains belong to the period of the disappearances, so that DNA work could concentrate there.

## **What the trench shows**

The lead archaeologist, Prof. Raj Somadeva of the University of Kelaniya, reported that the site “exhibits greater similarities to contexts characterized by formal burial practices than to clandestine burial sites documented in other parts of the world.” He also wrote that the evidence is “insufficient, in isolation, to support a definitive conclusion.”

The trench lies a few meters from the cemetery’s cremation platform. Most undisturbed skeletons were laid out straight. Newer graves cut into older ones, some with what the archaeologists identify as coffin nails. Children were buried with beads and adults with rings and bangles. A coin minted in 1870 lay with one skeleton, while plastic buttons and a polythene garland in other graves point to burials after the middle of the 20th century. Hindu families in the north have long buried young children instead of cremating them.

The evidence of possible killings is also serious. The Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka found in 2025 that most remains were unclothed and that there was “a reasonable likelihood that the burials were unlawful and pursuant to extrajudicial killings.” The area was under army control after 1995\. In 1998, Lance Corporal Somaratne Rajapakse, convicted in the 1996 rape and murder of the schoolgirl Krishanthi Kumaraswamy, said 300 to 400 bodies were buried at Chemmani.

The site may hold both an old cemetery and later burials of a different kind. Only dating can separate the two.

## **The archaeologist’s record**

Prof. Somadeva disputed the carbon dating at both Mannar and Matale. At Mannar he said it was “difficult to accept this carbon dating.” At Matale he had dated the burials to between 1986 and 1990 from a plastic fragment and a bottle, and argued that the samples were contaminated by flooding. The presidential commission found it “unsafe to place any reliance” on that claim.

His Chemmani report raises an epidemic as a possible explanation without citing any record of one. It contains an unfilled placeholder and age categories that add up to 98 percent. It says the skulls show no uniform orientation, although its own chart shows 72 percent facing northwest, a pattern the text does not explain. Magistrate S. Leninkumar said the court need not rely on the report.

## **Questions that remain**

Chemmani has become a central symbol for Tamil nationalist parties. They have used visits by the UN human rights chief and European ambassadors to present the trench as evidence of wartime killing. Gajendrakumar Ponnambalam, leader of the Tamil National People’s Front, has called Prof. Somadeva a Sinhala nationalist. ITAK and the front compete for the same voters.

If the families’ lawyers are confident that these are victims of the war, bomb-pulse dating would support them, so why have they not asked for it? If they distrust carbon dating, which method do they trust to establish when the dead were buried? And what result would lead them to accept that some of the burials are older than the war?

The police face questions too. According to accounts of the hearing, their request was for carbon dating, with no method, laboratory or safeguards specified.

Not all of the families’ lawyers are politicians. The magistrate has asked them to name four international laboratories capable of radiocarbon analysis by Dec. 14.